Ghosts in the Ruins review – Nitin Sawhney’s Coventry celebration fails to rise to the occasion

It’s 60 years because the consecration of the brand new Coventry Cathedral, constructed alongside the ruins of the medieval one which was destroyed by bombing in 1940. The opening of the constructing was marked by a variety of important music commissions, together with Arthur Bliss’s Beatitudes, Michael Tippett’s opera King Priam, and, most famously, Benjamin Britten’s Battle Requiem. And it’s Britten’s work that gives the place to begin for Nitin Sawhney’s Ghosts within the Ruins, commissioned as a part of Coventry’s yr as UK metropolis of tradition to mark the anniversary.

Promised as a site-specific work reflecting present-day Coventry’s function as a “metropolis of sanctuary”, it proved to be disappointingly bland. The primary a part of the 75-minute work is carried out within the new cathedral, the second among the many atmospheric ruins of the outdated, but it by no means manages to articulate the dialogue between previous and current and warfare and peace that I think is meant, and far of the work has the inert feeling of a dutiful faculty live performance.

Dialogue between past and present … the performance in the new cathedral.
Dialogue between previous and current … the efficiency within the new cathedral. Photograph: fivesix images

A distant recording of the Libera me from Britten’s requiem was supposed because the work’s ghostly starting, although on the primary night time its impact was ruined as latecomers had been nonetheless being noisily seated after it had begun. The choral setting by Sawhney that adopted – very effectively sung by the Coventry Cathedral choir – set the tone for what's a curiously Anglican sequence, far faraway from Sawhney’s traditional richly various musical palette. The choral numbers are interspersed with poems written and skim by native Coventry poets, led by town’s Poet Laureate, Emilie Lauren Jones and its Younger Poet Laureate, Hawwa Hussain, and interludes of pulsing ambient music from the violinist Eos Counsell and vocalist YVA, throughout which pictures from Coventry’s wartime previous and vastly numerous current (assembled by Mark Murphy) had been projected on to screens flanking the cathedral’s nave.

All of it unfolds very sedately, with no trace of drama or theatricality, however the second half, framed by the ragged partitions of the outdated cathedral, not less than affords a change of tempo: a sequence of choral numbers over a persistent rhythm for which the cathedral choirs are joined by members of the Spires Music choir and the Choir With No Identify, embellished by Counsell’s multi-tracked violin. The model is someplace between Carl Orff’s Carmina Burana and Philip Glass’s Koyaanisqatsi. The ending, nevertheless, is perfunctory, and the entire impact puzzling. It could have helped drastically to know what the texts for the choral settings had been; in a piece through which the phrases clearly matter a lot, they had been nowhere to be discovered.

Additional performances on 28 and 29 January

This text was amended on 29 January 2022 to right the spelling of Emilie Lauren Jones’s first identify.

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post